Commissions, made up of leading lawyers in each area of practice, developed specific, objective criteria to determine qualification for membership. They examined numerous professional attributes including legal experience, reputation, professionalism and community service. The commissions also considered each attorney’s standing in Martindale-Hubbell, certification as a legal specialist, and admittance to other recognized professional associations. The selection process was indeed rigorous. Finally, selectees were reviewed by the members of Arizona's Finest Lawyers Advisory Board.